Choosing how to structure a business is an important decision because the entity you select can affect taxation, ownership, liability, administration, and how business income is reported. Two options that frequently come up in discussions among small business owners are the Limited Liability Company (LLC) and the S Corporation.
However, comparing an LLC directly with an S Corporation can be confusing because they describe different aspects of a business. An LLC is generally a legal entity created under state law, while S corporation status is a federal tax election available to eligible entities.
Understanding that distinction is the first step toward making an informed business-structure decision.
What Is an LLC?
A Limited Liability Company, commonly called an LLC, is a business entity established under state law. One of its primary characteristics is that it generally provides liability protection to its owners, who are known as members.
An LLC can have one owner or multiple owners. Depending on applicable state law and the circumstances, members may include individuals and certain other entities.
For federal income tax purposes, an LLC does not automatically have one universal tax classification. Instead, its federal tax treatment generally depends on the number of owners and any elections made with the IRS.
A single-member LLC is generally treated as a disregarded entity for federal income tax purposes unless it elects to be taxed as a corporation. Its business activity is generally reported on the owner's federal tax return.
A domestic LLC with two or more members is generally treated as a partnership unless it elects corporate treatment.
An eligible LLC can also elect to be treated as a corporation and, if it meets the applicable requirements, may elect S corporation status. The IRS explains that an LLC making a valid S corporation election generally uses Form 2553 for that election.
This means that an LLC and an S Corporation are not necessarily competing legal structures. An LLC can, in certain circumstances, elect to receive S corporation tax treatment.
What Is an S Corporation?
An S Corporation is a corporation—or an eligible entity treated as a corporation—that has made a valid federal election to be taxed under Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code.
The principal federal tax feature is generally pass-through taxation. Instead of the corporation generally paying federal income tax on its ordinary business income in the same manner as a C corporation, income, deductions, and other tax items generally flow through to shareholders and are reported on their individual returns.
Businesses seeking S corporation status must satisfy specific eligibility requirements. Among other requirements, an S corporation generally must:
- Be a domestic corporation or an eligible domestic entity treated as a corporation.
- Have no more than 100 shareholders, subject to specific IRS rules for counting shareholders.
- Have only eligible shareholders.
- Have no nonresident alien shareholders, subject to limited statutory exceptions.
- Have only one class of stock.
- Not be an otherwise ineligible corporation under the tax rules.
The election is generally made using Form 2553, Election by a Small Business Corporation, subject to the applicable filing requirements and deadlines.
How LLC and S Corporation Taxation Can Differ
An LLC's federal tax treatment depends on its classification and elections. An LLC taxed by default as a disregarded entity or partnership can have different federal tax consequences from an LLC that elects S corporation status.
Both partnerships and S corporations are generally pass-through structures for federal income tax purposes. However, their rules for reporting income, owner compensation, distributions, employment taxes, basis, and other tax matters are not identical.
One area that often receives attention is self-employment and payroll taxation.
For an LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship or partnership, the owners' treatment of business income for self-employment tax purposes depends on the applicable tax rules and the owner's circumstances.
With an S corporation, shareholder-employees generally must receive reasonable compensation for services they provide to the corporation before non-wage distributions are considered. The treatment of wages, distributions, and employment taxes can therefore differ from the treatment of an LLC taxed under its default classification.
Because these rules can have significant consequences, business owners should evaluate the company's expected income, owner's role, compensation, expenses, and overall circumstances rather than choosing a tax classification based on a single tax consideration.
Other Factors Beyond Taxes
Federal taxation is only one part of the decision.
Business owners should also consider:
- State formation and compliance requirements
- State and local taxation
- Administrative responsibilities
- Payroll and employment-tax obligations
- Ownership restrictions
- Distribution rules
- Financing and investment plans
- Recordkeeping requirements
- Liability protection
- Costs associated with maintaining the entity
The appropriate structure can vary considerably from one business to another.
LLC vs. S Corporation: What Should Business Owners Consider?
The important question is not simply whether an LLC or an S Corporation is "better." In many cases, an LLC can actually be the legal entity while S corporation status represents its federal tax classification.
For example, an owner may establish an LLC under state law and later elect to have that LLC taxed as an S Corporation for federal purposes, provided the LLC and its owners meet the applicable requirements.
Before making an election, business owners should consider both the current tax situation and the expected future development of the company.
Final Thoughts
Choosing a business entity and federal tax classification can influence how income is reported, how owners are compensated, and what compliance responsibilities the business must meet.
Because the rules can vary based on ownership, income, state law, and other circumstances, there is no universal structure that works for every business.
Business owners should review their options with a qualified tax professional and, when appropriate, a business attorney before forming an entity or changing its federal tax classification. This article provides general educational information and should not be treated as legal or individualized tax advice.
Do you have any other questions? Send us an email at info@contnowtax.com and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible.
You can also send us a message through the WhatsApp button next to this message.